![](\"https:\/\/static.independent.co.uk\/static-assets\/images\/newsletter\/sport\/sport-135x135.png\")
<\/p>\n<\/p>\n
Winning ugly, it is said, is a hallmark of great sides, but it can be an indicator of an average one, too. What, then, are England, who have one foot in the Rugby World Cup quarter-finals after beating Japan? For 60 minutes on Sunday they produced a performance that only a mother could love \u2013 but a final quarter acceleration ensured they took five pool points away from a tricky evening.<\/p>\n
It may depend on how you view a Rorschach contest of a game and the merits of England\u2019s kick pressure strategy. Take the positives, as England were understandably inclined to afterwards, and a bonus point win was job very much done. Japan are not the force of four years ago but produced a stern defensive showing for good periods of the fixture. Their trademark attacking invention tested England\u2019s own ramparts, but these held firm \u2013 one try conceded in two games is an excellent return.<\/p>\n
There must also be some benefit of the doubt extended to both sides for Sunday night\u2019s sloppiness in slippery conditions. The humidity of the ongoing French heatwave is causing all teams problems in handling and taking contact. Errors have been a regular theme of virtually every game at this tournament.<\/p>\n
\u201cUltimately the important thing is that the players find a way,\u201d Steve Borthwick reflected afterwards. \u201cIn these conditions it was challenging for both teams.<\/p>\n
![](\"https:\/\/static.independent.co.uk\/2023\/08\/07\/11\/SEI166845196.jpg\")
\n![](\"https:\/\/static.independent.co.uk\/2023\/09\/18\/12\/0ee5ffb41fdfc5b9209e3026d6fb8599Y29udGVudHNlYXJjaGFwaSwxNjk1MTE1MTUw-2.73771611.jpg\")
\n![](\"https:\/\/static.independent.co.uk\/2023\/09\/17\/22\/GettyImages-1687250392.jpg\")
<\/p>\n
\u201cJapan kicked the ball 37 times. I\u2019m not sure when you\u2019d see a Japan team kick the ball 37 times. That gives you a sign of the nature of it. In Fiji\u2019s win [against Australia], they scored one try off a box kick. That tells you a lot about what the challenge is.<\/p>\n
\u201cWe knew from what every bit of information was telling us that the last quarter was going to be an important quarter, it was going to be tight. The last quarter was where we needed to accelerate and the boys did that.\u201d<\/p>\n
The boos apparent during the first hour in Nice suggested that England\u2019s fans aren\u2019t totally buying in, though Elliot Daly insisted afterwards that the displeasure expressed by supporters was inaudible on the pitch. But come full time, five points were in the bag.<\/p>\n
Much of the frustration appeared to stem from a single question – why are England kicking so much? Words to that effect, often accompanied by an expletive or two, bounced around the rafters throughout the game in Nice, and dominated the discussion on the trams back into town.<\/p>\n
The approach partly comes out of the lack of time that Steve Borthwick and his staff have had with the squad, with the time to build complexity and cohesion in attack over a four year cycle not afforded to the coaches. A kick pressure game brought quick dividends at Leicester and is proving an effective strategy in a tournament where holding on to the ball has proved tricky.<\/p>\n
![](\"https:\/\/static.independent.co.uk\/static-assets\/images\/mobile-stores\/Amazon_Prime.svg\")
<\/p>\n
Access unlimited streaming of movies and TV shows with Amazon Prime Video<\/p>\n
Sign up now for a 30-day free trial<\/p>\n
<\/p>\n
Access unlimited streaming of movies and TV shows with Amazon Prime Video<\/p>\n
Sign up now for a 30-day free trial<\/p>\n
Kicking remains a sometimes misunderstood element of professional rugby union. A majority of games are won by teams who kick for more metres than their opposition, while France, Ireland and South Africa, the three best sides at this tournament, all have strong, varied kicking games that they utilise well. <\/p>\n
The easy conclusion is that teams should therefore kick as much as possible. As ever, it is not that simple. In American football, there is a correlation between rushing yards and success \u2013 teams that run the ball more win most games. But there is no causation \u2013 winning teams tend to have their rushing totals inflated by a more conservative gameplan to kill the clock and avoid potentially costly turnovers.<\/p>\n
It is unclear, data analysts suggest, how much this is true of kick metres in rugby, too, with the different dynamics of the sport and less developed analytical study making it harder to assess.<\/p>\n
But kick well and the nature of modern rugby union makes putting boot to ball a more efficient use of possession than might first appear. Given the physicality and intensity of breakdown contest, it makes little sense to play phases inside your own half, where any penalizable ruck error will grant the opposition either three points or a punt into your 22.<\/p>\n
As the phase count grows, the chance of a turnover logically increases. France seldom play for more than five rucks before kicking and reloading, knowing that if a break is not made early in the passage, little is gained by expending further energy. Appropriately resourcing rucks in outside channels is harder, which can sometimes explain why outside backs turn down chances to take a man on.<\/p>\n
England aren\u2019t the only ones doing it, either. What was striking about Fiji\u2019s win over Australia was how the Pacific Islanders largely abandoned their natural inclination to play late on and instead engaged the Wallabies in extended periods of punting, both draining time out of the game and preventing opportunities for Australia to win penalties. Creative attacking kicking can be a weapon, too – see George Ford\u2019s lovely left-footed lob wedge for Freddie Steward against Japan, or Manie Libbok\u2019s no-look version last weekend.<\/p>\n
![](\"https:\/\/static.independent.co.uk\/2023\/09\/18\/15\/newFile.jpg\")
<\/p>\n
Freddie Steward\u2019s aerial ability has been utilised well by England <\/p>\n
Borthwick\u2019s side have shown intelligence in the way that they have used Steward\u2019s large wingspan and aerial acumen as a swooping bird of prey, while scrum half Alex Mitchell has also been stationed in the backfield as an extra high kicking option. Kicking accurately and chasing well are obviously key, but these are the parts of England\u2019s game that have worked best so far, allied with the fitness improvements for which Aled Walters deserves credit.<\/p>\n
With intelligent manipulation of the backfield during kick passages, you can create counter-attacking opportunities. Kicking to contest can work similarly \u2013 a good aerial chase can cause chaos or win back advanced possession. This is where France, for example, excel, morphing out of the kicking exchange and having the intricacy of handling and athleticism to exploit the spaces, picking out weary forward chasers, mismatches or misshapen defensive lines.<\/p>\n
The question for England is whether they have the players to do that. Marcus Smith has impressed off the bench and in training at full-back and could be given a starting opportunity against Chile, while Owen Farrell is back available too to create intriguing midfield options. England will still need more strings to their bow to mix it with the best sides but, in time, their hope is that the attack will come.<\/p>\n
\n![](\"https:\/\/static.independent.co.uk\/2023\/09\/17\/21\/newFile.jpg\")
\n![](\"https:\/\/static.independent.co.uk\/2023\/09\/17\/21\/newFile-1.jpg\")
<\/p>\n
\u201cWe are not happy with where we are attack-wise,\u201d said Wigglesworth on Monday. \u201cBut that is not to do with the kicking game. It is not separate from it, either. It is all part of the same stuff. We want to kick the ball brilliantly so we either get the ball back brilliantly or we kick to score.<\/p>\n
\u201cIt\u2019s definitely better to kick for position than lose the ball. What we have seen in this World Cup so far, the most successful teams have had a very skilled, efficient kicking game. We are working on ours to make sure it is in the best position it can be.\u201d There\u2019s a long way to go but England won\u2019t be straying too far from their successful strategy just yet.<\/p>\n